Our Move Away from "Zero Config"


Throwback Post – This post was originally posted on February 19, 2016 on the old Nanobox blog. The shift in approach discussed in this post has been the driving force in making Nanobox what it is today.

Throughout this article, there with be "Throwback Notes" (TBN) that provide context and some clarification regarding changes that have happened since.


In our initial vision of Nanobox, our hope was to create a system that would scan your codebase and auto-detect/auto-configure what it needed to run. While this level automation sounds great on paper, we found that it feels too magical for most. Initial feedback was that it felt like control was taken away, and we totally understand. This helped us to realize that, moving forward, we need to put more control of the process into your hands.

To help conceptualize what we feel Nanobox needs to be, we’ve studied LEGO to see what makes them so popular.

The LEGO Metaphor

Legos tapped into my love of creating; bringing something into existence that didn’t exist before. It’s that same love and passion led me to where I am today and I’m betting that, on some level, it’s the same for you.

What made LEGO so great was that rather than giving me a pre-built, glued-together pirate ship, they gave me all the pieces I needed to build a pirate ship. The set came with directions, but I didn’t have to follow them. I could do whatever I wanted and I loved the creative freedom.

We’ve placed LEGO on a spectrum consisting of 3 parts: A pre-built pirate ship, LEGO blocks, and a block of wood.

The Lego Spectrum

We’ll start with the opposite ends of the spectrum:

The Pirate Ship

It’s a pirate ship. It’s cool, but you have no say in how it’s designed or built. It is what it is and there’s not much you can do to change it.

Development Parallel: A pre-defined solution that works, but may not be exactly what you want or need. I won’t say the original direction of Nanobox was all the way at this end of the spectrum, but it was getting close.

The Wood Block

You can create pretty much anything out of this wood block, but it will be time-consuming and difficult.

Development Parallel: Building an infrastructure from scratch. It’s possible, but time-consuming, difficult, and can require expertise you may not have.

Legos

LEGO provides building blocks that can be used to build just about anything. They come in different shapes and sizes, but they follow standards and patterns that allow them to all work together.

Development Parallel: Nanobox. This is what we aim to provide: a system in which all the necessary “building blocks” are available in the form of engines and services, but you put them together how you’d like. These “blocks” follow standards and patterns so they work together, but the tedium is eliminated. You’re given the pieces necessary to build your vision.

Changes to Nanobox

With this shift in thinking, we’re implementing changes to give you more control.

Emphasis on the Boxfile

The Boxfile is a simple yaml config file that defines what services and configuration your app needs to run. Up to this point, Boxfiles have been optional since engines have carried the weight of assuming your app’s needs.

TBN: The Boxfile has since been changed to the boxfile.yml.

Engines no longer make assumptions about the needs of your app (more on that below). Boxfiles now carry the full weight of app configuration, letting you to explicitly define your app’s needs. Because of this shift, Boxfiles are now required.

Using the LEGO metaphor, the Boxfile is where you tell Nanobox what blocks you need and how they should fit together.

Simplified Engines

By shifting the burden of configuration into the Boxfile, engines have been greatly simplified. The original scope of engines included scripts that would “sniff” your codebase and auto-detect the needs of your app. The sniff process, while cool, wasn’t fool-proof and required a lot of upfront work by engine developers to get it to work properly.

Engines will no longer try to auto-detect the needs of applications other than the primary runtime. All services and configuration will be specified in your Boxfile.

No More Overlays

TBN: Overlays essentially let you layer an engine on top of another engine so you didn't have to reproduce functionality across engines. While it looked good on paper, in practice, it was a mess.

We know this was a short-lived feature, but with the new structure of engines, overlays are no longer necessary or feasible. The original purpose of overlays was to easily layer the functionality of multiple engines into one, removing the need to duplicate auto-detection and code configuration. With the reduction of engine auto-detection capabilities, this is no longer necessary.

Another reason overlays are being removed is because we’re changing how engines are stored. Previously, engines had to be published to and hosted on Nanobox in order to be used. Now, engines will be hosted elsewhere, such as Github. Overlays will not work with this setup.

No More Enginefiles

Enginefiles existed only to allow engines to be published to Nanobox. Since the need for publishing has been removed, enginefiles are no longer necessary.

The Registry

The Registry (name pending) will be a searchable catalog of engines, services, Boxfiles, and quickstarts (codebases pre-populated with a Boxfile). Anybody can create engines and services and add them to the registry, allowing you to find and use them. You can also share Boxfiles built for specific frameworks, making it easy to share and see what others have done to get apps running. To go back to the LEGO metaphor, this will be your bucket of blocks.

TBN: We still think it'd be good to have something like this in the future, but for now, the Registry idea has been shelved in favor of Github's search functionality.

Gearing Up for a Production Offering

Everything we’ve done over that last few months has been in preparation for a production offering. We’re getting really close to a private beta and would love some help. If you’re interested in being a part of the Nanobox beta, go to nanobox.io and click “Sign up for the Private Beta”.

TBN: We're now out of beta 😉.

Thanks for the support. You’re awesome!

Scott Anderson

Designer, code-dabbler, writer, foodie, husband, and father. Core Team Member at Nanobox.

Subscribe to Nanobox

Get the latest posts delivered right to your inbox.

or subscribe via RSS with Feedly!